The tree this year came from the Pisgah National Forest in the southern Appalachians in western North Carolina. It's a 78-foot-tall red spruce affectionately named "Ruby" (shortened from the spruce's scientific name, Picea rubens).
This post has caused me to reevaluate how I approach this subject, and I value the way you've questioned my presumptions and pushed me to think about other viewpoints. I appreciate the links and resources you've included for additional reading, and your research is impressive. I know I'll need to refer to this page as I continue to learn and develop, so I've bookmarked it and will most certainly return to it in the future.
